I ordered Vintage Brown but was shipped Dark Brown instead. I decided to keep it, as I think with a little wear the boots will break in and weather nicely. Keep this in mind, though, if Vintage Brown is what you want.
The boots are nice, fully lined with sheepskin and well constructed. They are narrow, but comfortable for me. Heeding the other reviews, I ordered a half size smaller than usual and they are still a bit long.
There is no arch support built into this boot, the insole is flat. I inserted an orthotic insole but there's just barely room for it.
I don't like the painted-on dark highlighting that covers the toes and heel area, but I hope with some weathering, it won't be as noticeable.
Overall this is a well made and comfortable boot, perfect for jeans and khakis.

Update: I wore the boots for 14 hours the first day with no discomfort. The leather is stiff but comfortable. It will break in nicely. The dark brown finish has a burgundy - oxblood base color visible in full sun. I am considering sanding off the edge dressing on the sole to help weather it. I'm beginning to really dislike the fake burnishing applied to the heel and toe. It makes a fine, well made pair of boots look like a $79 special.
Update: I bought another pair in black. The black pair has a higher dome toe and thicker all-rubber sole and heel so it looks more like a work boot. I thought it might be helpful to post pictures so you can see what they look like in a non professional photograph.

Spend the extra money for these shoes, your feet, no, your whole body will thank you. I have a standing desk at work and cheaper shoes gave me massive foot and lower leg pain. People have complemented my shoes and they are versatile for work or casual wear. I've never regretted the money spent on these.

1 Year update: These shoes finally gave way, although the part that broke will surprise you. The inside leather wore away from where it rubbed with the hard (plastic?) heel support on the backside of the shoes. By this point, the rubber soles had hardly any tread left and the leather laces had worn out, although still usable. I contacted Frye and they couldn't fix or replace, but offered me a credit since I was in their 1 year warranty.

I like this shoes because they are made from genuine leather, the lining on the inside is real quality as well as the outside, I also like the hand made finish up to the minimum detail. Mi only complain is that those shoes are not made wider and take longer time to stretch them and make you feel comfortable walking with. At this point I feel ok walking in these shoes after wearing them several times. I am satisfied with the purchase. I recommend them.

First off, these boots are made very narrow. Also, they are annoying to put on because the leather laces do not allow the boot to expand whenever you're trying to put your foot in the boot. I have to unlace the very top and allow nearly the whole lace to pull through to expand the tongue and slip on the boot. After getting your foot in them, however, the boots are extremely comfortable with absolutely no break-in period. The narrow fit keeps your feet from sliding around and the construction is very sturdy. Highly recommended only if you have a narrow/normal width foot.

These are way too narrow. And sizing up doesn't really change the narrowness. The good thing is that the leather is VERY soft. So there's not a lot of broken in needed, and it will stretch a bit to fit wider feet. Overall somewhat happy with these after they stretched a bit. I was very close to returning them because they just felt toooooooo narrow when initially putting them on. Wish they actually come in a wider option.